Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Patriotism wavers at Notre Dame protest

Published: Sunday, May 17, 2009

Updated: Wednesday, May 20, 2009 12:05

Kari'smugshot

Editor-in-Chief Kari Wilberg

The 19 people arrested Saturday for trespassing during a protest against President Barack Obama speaking at Notre Dame's commencement ceremony Sunday really show how far this country has come.

The ability to protest is one of the many freedoms that Obama, as president of the United States, represents.

Not only that, but it wasn't too long ago black people were forced to the back of the bus, attend different schools and drink out of separate water fountains.

Are we backtracking?

No. Fortunately they aren't protesting his skin color, just his beliefs as a person and politician. While it is our civic duty as citizens to stand up for what we believe in, where has the patriotism gone?

The respect Obama was deemed worthy of the day he won the election and was named our president seems to be missing.

Many are protesting Obama's right to speak at the commencement ceremony because his beliefs concerning stem cell research and abortion directly contradict those of the Roman Catholic Church.

Everyone has a right to their own beliefs, but as Americans we should also remember where the rights to those beliefs come from and who we have to thank for them. If he were anyone else less dignified with the same beliefs, it is undeniable that he would not be invited to speak at such a prestigious commencement.

In many news reports concerning the event during the past couple of months, many have said Notre Dame officials could have picked a better candidate to speak, such as a doctor or a lawyer.

What if they had chosen a doctor they thought worthy because he had fought for his country in Iraq, but later discovered he supported stem cell research because his wife had been diagnosed with cancer?

Would he be replaced as a speaker?

He has the honorable resume and the respect, but would he be considered ill-fitted to speak at the ceremony simply because he wanted to find a cure to save his wife?

What about the pro-life everyone is chanting about? I'd label the man pro-life for wanting to save his wife's life.

This may be a far-fetched scenario, but think about it: A respectable person is turned away from such a great ceremony simply because his beliefs are different.

Gone are the days where such a powerful organization can be so narrow-minded and allow themselves to deny anyone with different beliefs.

So are people at Notre Dame really going to turn away the president of the United States because he has different beliefs?

No. Luckily, someone over there has a brain to know that if the president is willing to make a pit stop by their university and give a speech, they should be thankful.

It is guaranteed that few people at UCF, if any, have exactly the same beliefs.

It is also guaranteed that many people on the UCF campus voted for John McCain instead of Obama, but I know many republicans to still be extremely patriotic, no matter whom they voted for.

It is hard to believe that a UCF student, whether he or she is Catholic or Muslim, democrat or republican, wouldn't feel just a little bit honored when standing face to face with the most powerful man in the world. 

He decided to take time out of his 24-hour day job to speak to these students, and they should give him that same kind of respect in return.

Hopefully these protests don't leave the graduates at Notre Dame's next commencement disappointed because their address was given by some stuffy, 100 percent Catholic values good guy.

While that may make for less sign carrying and leave people with fewer jail bonds to pay, it's always better to have an interesting commencement speaker who can keep you awake during those long, drawn-out ceremonies.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

16 comments

CJ
Thu May 21 2009 18:06
Typo in the first sentence of the second paragraph. Should read:

For the "Catholics" who think Obama should be allowed to speak at Notre Dame, but should NOT be honored with a degree.

CJ
Thu May 21 2009 18:02
Let's look at the institution we are talking about here - the UNIVERSITY of Notre Dame, not the church of Notre Dame, not the seminary of Notre Dame, but a learning institution. Part of learning is the willingness to listen to and consider others opinions and viewpoints without agreeing with them. Is it really learning to pass up the educational opportunity to hear the thoughts and opinions of the President of the United States, a former constitutional law professor, a former Senator, and a former community organizer just because you disagree with his opinion?

For the "Catholics" who think Obama should be allowed to speak at Notre Dame, but should be honored with a degree. First, consider the educational and social achievements listed above. Second, consider that this position is basically saying that anyone who fails to follow Roman Catholic Church dogma should not be part of the University - and presumably, not receive a degree from the University. Well, that eliminates anyone not of the Roman Catholic Church (most of the world, including, but not limited to, Russian Orthodox Catholic, Greek Orthodox Catholic, and every other Eastern Rite Catholic Church), Catholics who are GLBTQQ, Catholics who have pre-marital sex, Catholics who divorce without the permission of the Church, Catholics who marry outside the Church, and any number of Catholics who do not adhere to other church doctrine. Using the approach advocated by some respondents to the original opinion, this would also exclude people who (like Obama) have never themselves broken one of the Ten Commandments, but fail to prevent others from doing so - which pretty much wipes out the rest of the population.

In conclusion, having an opinion and a morality based upon your religious beliefs is absolutely fine - but trying to silence someone because their beliefs and morals differ from yours is just wrong.

my name
Thu May 21 2009 05:09
I should stop clicking these because of good looking pictures. :(

Anyways,

Religion gives you the right to be closed minded so it’s ok if they protest and are unpatriotic. The same would happen if a Pope were to come to speak at UCF and get an honorary degree. Many people would protest because it's against their views.
In Notre Dame’s case, If you just believe in something you don't have to think about whether it's right or wrong because the bible you read gives you some obscure meaning and you take it to be fact.

It's best to do what UCF does and pick some speaker that nobody knows or has ever heard of. That way nobody is insulted and everybody is disappointed. The worst UCF speaker I heard was from some loser telling business majors not to be like American Airlines and to be like Continental. Awe inspiring right? No controversy though. The only memorable thing about that commencement was how boring the speaker was.

American
Thu May 21 2009 00:13
...the Central Florida Future once again showing liberal bias...
Your name
Wed May 20 2009 18:32
Your article misconstrues the entire reasoning and nature of the protest of Obama's speech at Notre Dame. The fundamental issue these individuals were protesting was not President Obama. The protests were aimed at Notre Dame for their invitation of President Obama, and more importantly their offering of an honorary degree to an individual whose beliefs and actions stand in stark contrast to the Catholic church's stance on abortion.

This has nothing to do with trying to silence an opposing view. It has to do with individuals protesting the fact that a private Catholic university has decided to bestow a great honor an individual who has actively fought, and has vowed to fight in the future, for abortion legislation that stands against the moral stance of the Catholic Church. An average citizen has no influence over public policy regarding abortion, thus rendering your example of a pro-choice lawyer giving a commencement address at Notre Dame largely irrelevant. President Obama is not an average citizen, however. He presides in the most powerful office in the world, and has used his public office to vehemently support the "right" to a medical procedure considered by the Catholic Church as a moral travesty. For Notre Dame to bestow upon this individual their highest honor is certainly an action worthy of protest.

Julie
Mon May 18 2009 01:42
I have to disagree with your article. Notre Dame is a Catholic institution. Catholics believe that life is sacred and that life begins at conception. Thus, for Catholics, abortion is equivalent to murder. Therefor, anyone who supports this (as Obama indeed does) is not a good candidate for a commencement speaker at a Catholic university. Imagine if the president of the USA was someone other than Obama....someone that strongly supported a citizens right to own a slave.....would this hypothetical president be a good choice to speak at our University? No. Because we believe in freedom and condemn slavery. Well, ofcourse slavery is evil, but murder is even worse, and especially when we're talking about the murder of innocent children. And even though you may disagree on that definition of abortion, that is the definition of abortion that Catholics believe in, therefor honoring a man who supports abortion is simply something that a Catholic institution should not be doing.
tidalos
Sun May 17 2009 18:59
I didn't even get through reading the whole artical. I only clicked on it because the chick in the picture was hot. Why is the picture for the artical her face?
Lou
Sun May 17 2009 17:11
I think I may be a bit dumber for having read this article. About the only thing you have correct here is the idea that all Americans have the right to their own beliefs. When you say that we should remember where those rights come from, I wonder where you think they come from. Do you think they come from the government? Is not our government supposed to be directly representative of us, the people? So shouldn't that mean that these "rights" come from us? It seems as if you are implying that we should be lucky that we these rights.
The 1st amendment of our great Constitution allows for the freedom to assemble. Plain and simple. As long as no other laws are being broken it should be allowed, and in many cases encouraged, when any issues stands to be debated.
I think, however, the problem most have with this whole situation is not so much whether he should speak at ND but that he is being honored with a degree. I personally could care less but those who have issues with it should be allowed to voice their opinion. They are doing so as are you and I.
Jay
Sun May 17 2009 17:08
"Also, millions upon millions of innocent lives are murdered each day, and 90% of them is because the girls can't keep their legs closed, not because of incest or rape... "

Wow, such a sexist statement, the men having sex with these women must not be to blame at all.

Lucien
Sun May 17 2009 17:04
The Catholic church is moral and that's all they have. The pope, cardinals, and bishops live in almost shocking opulence while they tell poor people that pick through the garbage to survive that they can't use condoms to prevent conception of children they can't afford to feed. They tell people with HIV not to use condoms, so innocent wives are infected. Catholic priests molested thousands of young children around the world and the church hierarchy protected them, allowing them to continue molest. What kind of morals exactly are you talking about. God entrusted women with the ability to bring children into the world. It is a sacred trust between God and them. It is not the business of the church.
Mayu
Sun May 17 2009 16:55
actually dennis, you need to wake up. I fought my butt off trying to get these priests excommunicated. It's the liberals in the church who fight to make them simply go away without serious punishment.

Also, millions upon millions of innocent lives are murdered each day, and 90% of them is because the girls can't keep their legs closed, not because of incest or rape...

Child molesters in the church, you're talking less than 1% of priests.

Mayu
Sun May 17 2009 16:53
again, he is the president, fine, let him speak... but do not honor him with an honorary degree until he STOPS supporting abortion and WILL support the born alive infant act providing medical care to babies born alive after botched abortion attempts. This is the LAW of the catholic church, that all life is precious, even the unborn... we believe life begins at conception... you do not chose lower taxes (which haven't happened) over life, you do not choose more jobs (which as it turns out, has gotten worse than better) over life, you do NOT choose promises/false promises over the sanctity of life.

this has been an unchangable law since the origins of the Catholic church back in Christ's time. you can not honor a man who fights for the right to kill the unborn. You can let him speak yes... but to vote for him, to honor him with honorary degrees, to stand in ovation for him, as a Catholic... is sick. This is why the Catholic church is doomed. Liberals. The only reason most of these pro-choicers are Catholic... is for the title of being called 'Catholic'. They are silent Catholics. They go to church only for show.

Dennis
Sun May 17 2009 16:53
The Catholic Church has, literally, thousands of ordained employees who have been found guilty of child molesting.
Where are your protests about those poor children, allowed to be molested by your religious leaders. The molesters were also not punished, but moved to other areas, to molest more innocent children. Mayu, you are guilty by your lack of protest of supporting these same individuals. Wake up.
SanDiegoView
Sun May 17 2009 16:53
"...the most powerful man in the world."

It is not the rich man or the office that one holds that is actual power. Real power is found with the man who knows how to pray.

Scott
Sun May 17 2009 16:51
What is wrong the logic of people in this countr? They call Bush a murderer and liar but fairminded and conscienceous people cannot use their constittion rights without saying he is being disrepected. It would be laughable if it were not so disgusting. Why do you people always have to bring race into everything. My question is, when will he juts be the president without all the black history and other baggage? When do white Americans (who elected Obama) get freed from what others did in the past? My answer is never as long as it keeps paying dividends for those who want to control.
Mayu
Sun May 17 2009 16:45
this is a CATHOLIC institution. The only thing the catholics have are our morals, beliefs and values that are of any worth. The Church has said abortion is MURDER, and there are references in the bible that abortions are MURDER. This is infallable. there is no questioning this as a catholic. Catholics who claim to be pro-choice are NOT true Catholics and are not recognized by the church.

That being said... Obama is for abortion, has hired a pro-late term (when a child can survive outside of the womb) politician to his cabinet, he has refused to sign the born alive infant act to protect children born alive after a botched abortion attempt, leaving them to die long and lonely deaths... and he has reinacting taking our taxpayer dollars and sending them over seas so foriegners can have abortions on our dime.

if this is a TRUE Catholic institution...even if they had him speak they should never have honored him with an honorary degree.

he supports murder. He goes against EVERYTHING the church stands for. Sometimes I question his supposed Christianity... (He forced one college to cover up any religious symbol they had out before his speech... the national day of prayer was kept quiet this year... he's for abortion... there's not much more he can do to slap God in the face)

and now this CATHOLIC institution is HONORING him... let him talk, sure... but honor him with an honorary degree for going against everything catholics believe in...

They should no longer be allowed to call themselves a CATHOLIC institution, because they just went against everything Catholics are suppose to believe in and stand up for... all for the "prestige" of having the first black president speak at their campus. That's called prideful and pride is one of the 7 deadly sins.







log out